Contact: Jason Mercier, Budget
Research Analyst
(360) 956-3482
That's a (legislative) wrap
by Bob Williams, President
There is good news and bad after a three-and-a-half-month legislative session
ended April 27. The good news is that some of EFF's key recommendations
were adopted, laying the groundwork for more significant reforms. The bad
news is that 105 days wasn't long enough for some lawmakers this year, so
they're scheduled to start a special session on May 12 at a cost of $16,000
- $18,000 per day.
The major sticking point is the state budget for the next two years. This
is the most important piece of legislation lawmakers deal with since it
determines the priorities and spending for the entire state.
But that's not all they'll be addressing in the special session. In addition
to the state budget, Governor Locke has asked them to consider the Capital
Budget, unemployment insurance, charter schools, school testing and other
education issues, terrorism, homosexual rights, water law revisions, prescription
drugs, workers' compensation, community development financing, and a proposal
to allow shared leave time for state employees serving in the military.
(These are the session leftovers?) In Locke's words: "There's no reason
these items [non-budget issues] can't be completed within a day or two."
The governor is dreaming unless he gets personally involved in serious negotiations.
Performance audits
"Accountability" was this year's buzzword in Olympia and lawmakers
scrambled to prove they understood it. Most had good intentions when they
anxiously signed on to some "performance audit" bills. The bad
news: the bills were little better than internal audits, not independent
and comprehensive performance audits. The good news: most of those bills
died after citizens placed a full-page ad in The Olympian defining
and demanding true accountability. Implementation may require a citizen
initiative, but the foundation has been laid.
Operating Budget
House Democrats, under the leadership of Speaker Frank Chopp, are responsible
for the state's failure to adopt a budget. They didn't even pass their own
version of the budget until the 104th day of session, leaving no time for
negotiations. The delays prompted senators to break tradition and release
their own budget before the House on April 4.
The bad news: The House budget is not balanced and seeks $320 million in
tax increases on candy, gum, cigarettes (50-cent per pack increase), liquor
(5 percent increase in sales tax) and gambling. House members did not
pass the bills necessary to implement their budget, so they still do not
have a viable plan for the Senate to review and debate. Governor Locke supports
the House "sin" taxes despite his previously strong stand against
increases.
The good news: The Senate's budget proposal implements many EFF recommendations
and is balanced within existing revenue (no new taxes). Senators are so
far holding the line against taxes.
Capital Budget
The House and Senate did not reach an agreement on a Capital Budget for
2003-05. Both of their proposals would raise the state's debt limit from
7 percent to 8.5 percent. House members want to spend about $30 million
less than senators. Both budgets are full of pork and lack priorities.
Transportation
Lawmakers agreed on a five-cent per gallon gas tax increase, which will
take effect July 1. The tax will raise $4.1 billion over the next ten years
for transportation improvements. Unfortunately, the plan still lacks the
crucial elements for success: independent performance audits; meaningful
efficiency measures (such as repealed prevailing wage laws, repealed project
labor agreements, and provisions for competitive bidding); priorities based
on congestion relief; and project costs and start/stop dates.
When the bill passed, Secretary of Transportation Doug MacDonald stated
that he was both "elated and terrified" at the prospect of handling
such a big challenge. Given his department's track record for mismanagement
and lack of accountability, we're terrified, too. We'll be closely monitoring
their work.
Tuition for illegal aliens
Governor Locke is planning to veto a restriction on tuition funds adopted
by the legislature. His veto will allow illegal aliens to pay in-state tuition,
which means a large part of their expenses will be subsidized. They will
be receiving better education benefits than the soldiers returning from
the war!
Tax and fee increases
Here are some of the tax and fee increases passed this session. The list
may not be comprehensive at time of printing.
College tuition increased between 6-9 percent
Workers' compensation rates average increase of 29
percent this year
Unemployment insurance premiums average increase
of 15.4 percent this year
Taxes on nursing homes a shell game because the taxes
will be returned to nursing homes and the new "contribution"
will be matched by federal Medicaid, thus allowing them to collect even
more.
The special session starts May 12. The good news: your voice matters. Be
informed and involved through WashingtonVotes.org.
At a March 23, 2005, House Appropriations hearing on a bill to gut the voter-approved I-601 spending limit, Rep. Jim McIntire (D) asked a supporter of I-601’s two-third supermajority requirement for the legislature to raise taxes the following question:
"Can you name a time when we [legislators] have actually not just set it [supermajority requirement] aside by majority vote? I mean, this is in many respects a procedural motion that has no bearing. It’s a statutory constraint that cannot constrain any legislature that chooses as a majority to set it aside . . . have we ever used a supermajority [to raise taxes]?"